Is Abortion a Constitutional Right? Unraveling the Debate

Before delving into this discussion, it is essential to clarify that the topic at hand deals with the legality of abortion by the U.S. Constitution, not its morality or the underlying philosophical debates surrounding the issue.

The Constitutional Question

The question of whether abortion is a constitutional right is a deeply divisive and contentious one in American society. In many ways, the issue brings us to the heart of the Constitution's interpretation and the role of the judiciary in our democratic system.

The recent Supreme Court decision in the Dobbs v. Jackson case has further ignited the debate. Justice Alito's majority opinion states:

“We hold that Roe and Casey must be overruled. The Constitution does not refer to abortion, and no such right is implicitly protected by any constitutional provision, including the one on which the defenders of Roe and Casey now chiefly rely—the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.”

Constitutional Simplicity

One of the enduring strengths of the U.S. Constitution lies in its simplicity. If the Constitution and the Bill of Rights do not explicitly articulate a right, then, according to some interpretations, it does not exist as a Constitutional right. This logic asserts that the Roe v. Wade decision, which recognized the right to abortion, did not alter or modify the Constitution.

The Path to Constitutional Change

Amending the Constitution is a formidable process. It requires the people, rather than a few judges, to initiate and approve changes. Article V of the Constitution outlines the process of amending it, a method that thankfully does not leave the task in the hands of partisan judges.

A History of Amendments

Interestingly, throughout history, approximately 11,699 amendment changes have been proposed in Congress through 2016. Yet, only the 18th Amendment that established Prohibition was later repealed by the states. [Read more on this topic here]

Two Routes to Abortion Rights

If one wishes to establish abortion as a right or a legal option, two avenues are available:

1. Amendment via Article V: Two-thirds of state legislatures can call a Convention of States, and if the three-fourths vote to ratify a proposed amendment, it becomes a Constitutional right.

2. State Legislation: Alternatively, individuals can advocate for state legislatures to pass laws allowing abortion within their jurisdiction.

The ongoing debate around abortion and its status within the U.S. Constitution illustrates the inherent complexity and dynamism of constitutional law. It's a testament to the flexibility of our system, allowing us to navigate deep and often irreconcilable differences within our society.

This process is a beautiful demonstration of the power and responsibility vested in the people, whether the issue is abortion or any other right not currently explicitly stated in the U.S. Constitution.

Do you want to learn more about what you can do to act NOW! and save our Constitution?
https://www.thefifthprinciple.coop/wcid.html

Take your learning to the next level:

✍️ Join our course on faith here.
https://www.thefifthprinciple.coop/faith.html

✍️Learn about historical events that shape our future. Flashback to a Fabulous Future.
https://www.voiceamerica.com/show/4117/flashback-to-a-fabulous-future

✍️ Join us on our learning Journey to Plymouth, MA, on August 30, 2023 – September 4, 2023. Learn more here.
https://keap.page/ysn122/monument-to-our-fathers-tour.html

✍️ Join our Bible Study Group. Study the Bible through the lens of our Founding Fathers. We use David Barton’s Founder’s Bible when we meet once a week on Sundays at 6:00 p.m. Eastern. There is no charge for this class.
https://thefoundersbible.com/

✍️ To join our waiting list, sign up thru the following links:

For our Biblical Citizenship, and the American Campfire Revival courses. There is no charge for these courses.
https://www.thefifthprinciple.coop/membership.html

#homeschool, #history, #unitedstates, #consitution, #foundingfathers, #travel, #tour, #historical, #family, #bible, #biblical, #faith